What is McDuffie's intent with pointing fingers at others? The Oakley's other son was NOT caught on camera "choking" his brother. This has been a continual spin used by the convicted abusers. Sheriff detectives did a great job reviewing 1000's of video clips of many caregivers, including James' "brother", and determined the other caregivers whose actions were analyzed were not abusive. The ONLY caregivers seen intentionally hurting and causing James Oakley repeated mental suffering and pain were Michael Garritson and Matthew McDuffie.